Abstract

The selection and pre-treatment of reliable organic fractions for radiocarbon age determination is fundamental to the development of accurate chronologies. Sampling from tropical lakes is particularly challenging given the adverse preservation conditions and diagenesis in these environments. Our research is the first to examine and quantify the differences between radiocarbon ages from different carbon fractions and pretreatment protocols from tropical lake sediments. Six different organic fractions (bulk organics, pollen concentrate, cellulose, stable polycyclic aromatic carbon (SPAC), macrocharcoal >250 mu m and microcharcoal >63 mu m) were compared at six different depths along a 1.72 m long core extracted from Sanamere Lagoon, Cape York Peninsula, northern Australia. Acid-base-acid (ABA), modified ABA (30% hydrogen peroxide + ABA), 2chlorOx (a novel cellulose pre-treatment method) and hydrogen pyrolysis (hypy) were used to pre-treat the organic fractions. The oldest date is similar to 31,300 calibrated years before present (cal yr BP) and the youngest is similar to 2800 cal yr BP, spanning similar to 28,500 years. The smallest offset between the minimum and the maximum age for different fractions and across pretreatment methods at a given depth was found to be 832 years (between SPAC and pollen) and the largest similar to 16,750 years (between pollen concentrate and SPAC). The SPAC fractions pre-treated with hypy yielded older ages compared to all other fractions in most cases, while bulk organics yielded consistently younger ages. The magnitude and consistency of the offsets and the physical and chemical properties of the tested organic fractions suggest that SPAC is the most reliable fraction to date in tropical lake sediments and that hypy successfully removes exogenous carbon contamination.