Abstract

The present study aims to reconcile conflicting evidence from previous research on the role of objectivity in journalists' and citizens' information behaviors. Drawing on news quality frameworks and confirmation bias research, the article proposes a model of biased objectivity that was tested by a quasi-experiment with 430 journalists and 432 citizens in Germany. Results show that both perceived objectivity value (news quality perspective) and attitude consistency of a message (confirmation bias perspective) enhanced the informational value of a message, with objectivity value mediating the effect of attitude consistency on informational value perceptions (biased objectivity perspective). Journalistic professionalism did not moderate this relationship.