Culturally adapted meta-debriefing: a mixed-methods study of reflective practice in Spanish-speaking simulation faculty development in Chile

Armijo-Rivera, Soledad; Vergara, Karen; Vicencio-Clarke, Scarlett; Foss, Brynjar; Holtheuer, Marcia Maldonado

Abstract

Background: Simulation-based education has expanded across Latin America, creating demand for contextually relevant faculty development. Meta-debriefing, defined as a facilitated conversation following a debriefing, can strengthen debriefer performance. However, its implementation and effectiveness in Spanish-speaking settings remain underexplored. The CORE model (context, observation, reflection, and enhanced practice) provides structural guidance, but its adaptation to regional cultures has not been studied. Methods: We conducted a concurrent mixed-methods study of one experienced meta-debriefer interacting and facilitating 15 remote meta-debriefing sessions with interprofessional novice debriefers. Quantitative data were derived from audio-recorded sessions using DASH, SET-M, a CORE-aligned checklist, and a meta-debriefing pillars tool. Qualitative data consisted of written observer reports, analyzed using inductive content analysis, and triangulated across sources. Results: Quantitative analysis revealed high adherence to the CORE model and consistent demonstration of the four meta-debriefing pillars. Peer-assessed DASH scores ranged from 6.8 to 7.0, while SET-M items were consistently marked as achieved. Qualitatively, the meta-debriefer demonstrated behaviors aligned with psychologically safe, context-dependent, theoretically grounded, and formative facilitation. The meta-debriefer used cultural metaphors (e.g., “boli,” “cazuelas,” and a prisoner’s song) to clarify structure and normalize reflection. Five reflection strategies emerged as central to generating debriefer insight: (1) Structured reorientation, (2) constructivist linkage to clinical identity, (3) metaphorical framing, (4) strategic questioning (e.g., advocacy & inquiry, circular inquiry), and (5) emotional normalization. Conclusion: This study demonstrates how meta-debriefing, when implemented through culturally sensitive and structured approaches like CORE, supports transformative learning among simulation debriefers. Meta-debriefer’s relational style, use of shared narratives, and context-sensitive scaffolding activated learner-centered reflection. As meta-debriefing models gain traction in Latin America and beyond, this study highlights the value of culturally responsive faculty development strategies that integrate local language, values, and pedagogical traditions into simulation-based education. © The Author(s) 2025.

Más información

Título según WOS: Culturally adapted meta-debriefing: a mixed-methods study of reflective practice in Spanish-speaking simulation faculty development in Chile
Título según SCOPUS: Culturally adapted meta-debriefing: a mixed-methods study of reflective practice in Spanish-speaking simulation faculty development in Chile
Título de la Revista: Advances in Simulation
Volumen: 10
Número: 1
Editorial: BIOMED CENTRAL LTD
Fecha de publicación: 2025
Idioma: English
DOI:

10.1186/s41077-025-00380-0

Notas: ISI, SCOPUS