Parental refusal to mandatory vaccination in Chile. Ethical and legal challenges

Luca Valera; Paulina Ramos Vergara; Ignacio Porte Barreaux; Paula Bedregal García

Keywords: vaccination, vacunación, negativa a vacunar, grupos antivacunas, Programa Nacional de Inmunizaciones, Vaccine Refusal, Anti-vaccination Groups, National Immunization Program

Abstract

This article is an ethical and legal reflection about the current trend of parents to refuse vaccination of their children under a legal regime that establishes mandatory use of certain vaccines. We analyze the main arguments used by parents to refuse obligatory vaccination, i.e., the fear of the negative effects that vaccination may have on the child; the violation of the "right to autonomy"; religious or pseudo-philosophical beliefs; and the resistance to the State intervention in personal or family matters. Therefore, this statement implies a necessary ethical analysis of childhood vaccination. Finally, it will be discussed the responsibility of parents and the State-the health authority-in the care of minors. Vaccination is a benefit for both the inoculated and the community, the best preventive policy. At the same time, it is considered a complex case that demands a profound debate, whose purpose should be the transition from an apparent conflict between parents and the State, to convergence for the care of minors. In other words, it is emphasized the fact that parents, beyond the fulfillment of a heterogeneous normative duty, must act motivated by voluntary adherence to the best interest of the child and the community.

Más información

Título según SCOPUS: Parental refusal to mandatory vaccination in Chile. Ethical and legal challenges [Rechazo de los padres a la vacunación obligatoria en Chile. Desafíos éticos y jurídicos]
Título según SCIELO: Rechazo de los padres a la vacunación obligatoria en Chile. Desafíos éticos y jurídicos
Título de la Revista: Andes Pediátrica, Revista Chilena de Pediatría
Volumen: 90
Número: 6
Editorial: Sociedad Chilena de Pediatría
Fecha de publicación: 2019
Página de inicio: 675
Página final: 682
Idioma: Spanish
DOI:

10.32641/rchped.v90i6.1002

Notas: WOS-ESCI, SCIELO, SCOPUS